Toll Free:              800-824-3629


Mishawaka:          574-259-5622

White Pigeon:      269-483-9300

Sturgis:                 269-651-1133

Our Mission

At McCarthy Insurance Group, our mission is to provide all of our customers, both individuals and businesses, quality protection and unparalleled service by using the best resources available in today’s insurance marketplace.


Exceeding the customer’s expectation is our top priority. This is why we are an independent insurance agency representing many different insurance companies. We are able to check with multiple insurance carriers to find the one that provides the broadest coverage at the best cost for each customer.


At McCarthy Insurance, we are committed to excellence. Our team of dedicated professionals work hard to know the current insurance markets, understand your unique needs, and guide you through the process of finding the coverage that is right for you.


You deserve an insurance agency that offers one-stop shopping, customized solutions, and a commitment to your satisfaction. Find out how much better the insurance process can be when you work with our professionals.



802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, IN  46544