Toll Free:              800-824-3629


Mishawaka:          574-259-5622

White Pigeon:      269-483-9300

Sturgis:                 269-651-1133

Our History

McCarthy Insurance Group was founded in 1959. While much has changed in the first half century, our mission of providing “Quality Protection and Unparalleled Service” remains the same.


We have been located in Mishawaka since the beginning and are committed to the Mishawaka community. Our current location demonstrates our commitment. We take great pride in renovating one of Mishawaka’s oldest buildings and making it beautiful and useful once again.


In 2008 we expanded to Michigan by opening an office in White Pigeon. We are proud to see that our commitment to outstanding service and quality insurance products is appreciated in that community. Due to the ongoing success of the White Pigeon location, we opened another office in Sturgis in 2011.


McCarthy Insurance Group has been and always will be dedicated to quality insurance products and services. We will continue to maintain the high principles and top notch customer service that has enabled us to succeed for over 50 years.


802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, IN  46544