Toll Free:              800-824-3629


Middlebury:          574-971-2220

Mishawaka:          574-259-5622

Sturgis:                 269-651-1133

White Pigeon:      269-483-9300


Thank you for contacting us.

An agent will be in contact with you soon.

Submitting Form...




get a quick quote

Protection for

your way of life

Just tell us what type of insurance you

are looking for and we'll shop the top insurance carriers to get

you the best coverage at the most affordable price.


like us on facebook

our products

Homeowners & Renters Insurance


Life & Health Insurance


Business Insurance


Automotive Insurance


Sign up to get updates on new/upcoming information about McCarthy Insurance

Submitting Form...

The server encountered an error.

orm received.

802 Lincolnway West

Mishawaka, IN  46544